I have three dogs Cody (Golden retriever) 2yrs, Kailee (BC) 1yr, Jasper(Min eskie) 16 wks. All three are live inside except for potty breaks and play and exercise time. My recently departed other two Goldens were also inside dog. I am a firm believer that most breeds, if not all, were bred to do a task and to be companions. Therefore should always be with thier humans.