Jump to content
BC Boards

Bonnie and Sheep


Maja

Recommended Posts

If I can get this link to work, here's a couple of vids of a 6 month old pup working calves. I'm not putting pressure on her, just letting her find balance and bring the stock to me. As you might be able to hear, she also takes a down with the whistle,

The first two links are the same :rolleyes:

 

The videos are very nice! I like the pooch sneaking over to the person watching, just like Bonnie :D

 

Mr. Donald,

I just noticed your last post, and I agree with everything you wrote. It may not always show in the movies since the dynamics of human-dog-stock situation is complex and I can't always assess the situation fast enough. I think, Bonnie is not a willful dog, if I rebuke her it's the end of the world for her. But I think that if I were harder on her I would break her.

 

Maja

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 226
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Interesting thread. We all must feel very tired.

 

Not sure you want my input but IMO whoever is handling this dog (Bonnie) is not giving it anything to do. Where is the work for the dog? (See, I never said the "C" word.)

 

Just because a dog overcomes a poor training method and makes a decent dog of itself doesn't mean it's an optimal training method. Just sayin'.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What do you suggest to give a 6 moth old pup to do?

 

I would be taking the sheep from point A to point B. A destination. So Bonnie can start to understand there's a reason for doing this. If you can't get that I'd start with just walking more. Straight lines to help her stay behind her sheep. Speed up your pace so she isn't so quick to move behind you. Not running but maybe quicker walking. When you've gone a ways, then turn and go a differet way. again, letting Bonnie see that you are taking the sheep somewhere instead of just turning circles, which I see you get caught up in doing cause you're trying to get Bonnie behind the sheep. If the sheep rush past you, turn yourself in a different direction and start walking so Bonnie has a reason to bring the sheep back to you.

 

Pick a tree, walk to that, then pick another tree and walk to that. eventually Bonnie should get the idea that you are doing something useful and the "ringing" (new word) will start to settle down.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kristen,

Sounds like a really good idea. I will put stakes from electric fence (they have a spike to drive them into the ground) and set out a route ahead of time and follow it.

 

Paula,

A lovely dog :rolleyes:.

Maja

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What do you suggest to give a 6 moth old pup to do?
Well, if you notice in the videos I posted of Dot at 6 months, I am letting her gather the stock and bring them to me--I keep moving all the time to change the balance point, and she has to think and figure out how to keep the calves together and then to being them to me,

A

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stockdogranch,

Yes, I saw it, i will try to do it that way.

-------------

 

OT: Just to clarify what I wrote about Kelly - I wasn't trying to say that there was anything good about the whole situation, but we didn't have much choice then, we had livestock we couldn't leave for a day or two to go somewhere to train at that time, and we needed a dog to help us manage the sheep. We tried our best to learn all we could, but without hands-on experience it was very hard. Bonnie was raised altogether different from Kelly.

 

Maja

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm sure your instructor will help you out. I will occassionaly start puppies at 6 m.o. , but mainly later because I'm lazy. Take sheep from one place to another, short sessions, it shows a purpose.

 

One of the littermates to my oldest bitch was allowed to circle adnasium...for 2 years, because the instructor said she would eventually find her balance...outstanding agility dog but I think it really disappointed her owner that she didnt do well in herding.

 

cynthia

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyway, I will be interested to watch as Bonnie progresses. I'll also try to post more videos of Ranger as we progress.

 

J.

So am I, and please do post more vids of those dogs, the both of you. Combined with the discussion I think it´s extremely educational, you see what the starting dogs do, and read what their handlers want to accomplish. With the imput of experienced board members one gets a really good picture of the proces. Thumbs up!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One of the littermates to my oldest bitch was allowed to circle ad nasium...for 2 years, because the instructor said she would eventually find her balance...outstanding agility dog but I think it really disappointed her owner that she didnt do well in herding.

Well I certainly don't intend to do anything of the sort nor ever did :rolleyes: . She has some puppy license right now as I have been trying to explain. Like she had some very early when up to a certain point I never ever rebuked her, just silently made her do what she had to, and then came the time to teach her recall, and I did it the way V. Holland suggests and was consistent with it and she had better recall at the age of 4 months than my 11 year old bitch who is my very first dog.

 

In the mean time my two country bumpkins went to a national show and Bonnie got "Best Puppy" while Daisy got excellent and came second in Junior bitches . In case you are wondering why I am bothering with shows for working dogs: in Poland it's the only way it makes sense. There is only KC that really counts as a place with purebred dogs, and they require 3 shows to get a breeding license.

 

Maja

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So all those things are taught dry with no sheep?

How do they know what to take a hold of?

 

I second the idea of trainign some stuff the dog can do with out needing sheep . I am much more confortable kniwing that I can get this dog to stop no matter what and come away from teh sheep n matter whaty and I trained it all on a ball.

 

 

First I taught him to lie down instantly (voice and whistle) then I taught him to lie down mid chase of his ball, then I taught him to come away from his ball on a that'l do command (when he arrived I threw another ball in the oppositied direction as a reward). Then I taught him to walk on, stop and lie down all walking tward his ball both away from me and toward me.

 

Now that he is training with sheep and doing pretty well, I find his stop is getting less reliable as he gets more and more exciting and confident with the sheep, so I am upping his stop training away from sheep. Im confident it will come back again.

 

The thing hs is worst at is working away from his sheep - he alwasy wasnts to come in too close, so now I am teaching him to "go out" from a ball on the floor - only when he drifts off the ball, is he allowed in to the circle to get his ball.

 

Hope that made sense - kinda hard to explain, in words.

 

Anyway. good luck with your dog and hope you have as much joy and fun as we are having. Denise x

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I second the idea of trainign some stuff the dog can do with out needing sheep .

 

snip

 

The thing hs is worst at is working away from his sheep - he alwasy wasnts to come in too close, so now I am teaching him to "go out" from a ball on the floor - only when he drifts off the ball, is he allowed in to the circle to get his ball.

 

The thing about dry training (off stock training of commands) is IMO commands should be learned (felt) in the context of the situation and the stock being worked at that time. Distances and attitudes of both stock and dog are dynamic because it's an interaction between live animals. The effectiveness of a "get back" distance for example is related to the flight zone of the specific stock at that time in a specific situation. What is the flight zone of a ball - a non living object?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

With my highly limited experience I feel that it is worth while to teach commands off-stock that run counter to the instinct, that is recall - the dog does not want to be with me when we are with the stock. When on stock the dog (at least my dog) of course "forgets" about it anyhow, but she still understands the command, which would be rather difficult to explain to her on stock. I teach lie down off stock, but my previous dog had a real good natural clap so I taught her down on stock naming i as she did it herself. It seems the fastest way. With Bonnie I taught her lie down off stock but its was entirely by (I don't know what you call it in English properly) catching her at doing it anyhow and just giving it a name. After a while she caught on. It was very easy. Then on stock, if she ever does lie down of her own I give her the command to reinforce the idea.

 

Now I have a question concerning recall- Bonne has got excellent recall off stock. With livestock she comes but she brings the sheep with her every time :rolleyes:. She doesn't come to me, but if I tell her to lie down she obeys, and I can go over to her and put the leash on her and we can walk away. I do it more than once in every session so that she knows that leash doesn't mean end of herding. How do you suggest I proceed from here? When she is unable to to move the sheep e.g. they are in a small enclosure and she sees the through the fence, she comes immediately.

 

Since this is a video thread here is Bonnie's recall off livestock with distractions, age 5 months:

http://www.youtube.com/user/majawn#p/u/20/U1GANFNKbU4

Maja

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Now I have a question concerning recall- Bonne has got excellent recall of stock. With stock she comes but she brings the sheep with her :rolleyes:. She doesn't come to me, but if I tell her to lie down she obeys,a nd I can come and put the leash on her and we can walk away. i do it more than once in every session so that she knows that leash doesn't mean end of herding. How do you suggest I proceed from here?

 

maja

One clinician I respect would do it this way - the dog has brought the sheep towards you, the sheep have settled, and you have had her lay down (since she is at the balance point, this is relatively easy for her). Repeating "lie down" if necessary in a soft voice, walk past the sheep and by the dog, telling her "That'll do, here" as you walk by her so that she is walking with you away from the sheep. To call her off when the sheep are between the two of you is not an easy way to teach the recall off stock.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sue,

 

Thank you :rolleyes: . I always make sure that there are no sheep between us and that the sheep are still - otherwise it would be pretty hopeless at this stage. The recall used to be easier when she was unable to move sheep on her own -without me near the sheep. I could walk past the sheep and past her and call her off, and she'd come. If she didn't come but tried to work sheep I would call her every time she was between me and the sheep, and then she would come. But now she can bring the sheep every time, so she seems to be saying "ok, I am coming, I'm coming, and I am bringing the sheep too." Maybe I just have to be patient?

 

maja

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Are you making corrections when she does this, using your voice and/or body to let her know that's not what you want and blocking her from doing it? Getting between her and the sheep and taking her off (if she lies down and you put a leash on her to take her off initially, don't scold at all once she's laid down for you)?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maja, I do like Sue describes: I get the pup to stop and then I walk through the sheep (by going through the sheep I can walk straight toward the pup, which helps the pup to hold the stop, whereas if I circled around the sheep, the pup should circle in the opposite direction to go to balance, which I don't want when I'm trying to call the pup off) and toward the pup, repeating the lie down in a calm voice. Because I am now between the dog and the sheep I can control access to the sheep, so even if the pup gets up and tries to go around the sheep again, I am right there and can block the youngster from getting to the sheep (I'm closer to the sheep so can circle as the dog circles, keeping myself between the dog and the sheep and so preventing the pup from actually working). I repeat the lie down command and then when the pup stops, walk up to the pup and ask it to come with me. I walk a little way away and then will turn and let the pup to do a small outrun to go gather the sheep again, so that it doesn't think that every time I stop it and call it off the "fun" is over. You can see this technique in action in the videos that were posted of Ranger.

 

J.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I use what Julie describs too and sometimes I've found that if I"m really fighting the dog (she keeps trying to balance the sheep to me so keeps moving around me) I'll squat down between the sheep and the dog and call her to me right there. They are more likely to come to me since coming to me is moving towards sheep also.

But I try to get away from that quickly cause it's sorta like tricking the dog to come to you. So again like Julie describes, sometimes we go right back to working so the dog doesn't think the fun is always over when I say that'll do or call the dog to me.

When working on getting Dew off sheep we kinda got in the habit of calling her off and resending her on little outruns, it became a habit for Dew so then we had another issue to work on. But we did get through it quickly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"I'll squat down between the sheep and the dog and call her to me right there. They are more likely to come to me since coming to me is moving towards sheep also."

That sounds very interesting. I don't think I'd have trouble going in that direction, and maybe she would get into the habit of coming this way and then I could call her off the other way.

 

 

Kristen, Julie and Sue,

I think I do all the things you are describing, since I was taught that with my previous dog, and she has an excellent recall. So -

1. I calm the sheep down,

2. tell Bonnie to lie down,

3. she does

4. go through the sheep to her,

5. she still lies down.

Now I can put a leash on her and we can walk away.

 

But if I walk past her, away from the sheep and away from her and then call her, she gets up to come and then some force (I wonder what? :rolleyes: ) makes her go round the sheep and bring them to me. I will try to video what it looks like on Thursday, maybe I am missing something.

 

Maja.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't see you are missing anything, at least not in understanding the suggestions you have been given. She is a very young dog, just entering adolescence (if I recall, about six months old?), and it is very natural for her to want those sheep and to bring them to you. The difference is that with the steps you have outlined, you would be putting yourself as well as Bonnie in a position to use your body pressure as well as voice to block her and then to gently remove her when you want to call her off - instead of giving her the open option to ignore you and listen to her instincts (that are shouting for her to go get those sheep).

 

She seems keen and eager to gather for you - both good attributes, I would think!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes I agree with Sue. I can still see Dew think about going back to sheep after I have called her off. I like to see them eger for work. TO have a young dog come right off sheep would make me wonder. It's just a work in progress for Bonnie. Being the tender age that she is, I consider it just fine that she is still trying to figure out a way to get to sheep.

 

So maybe only take a step away from her and sheep, if she comes, tomorrow take 2 steps. If not, maybe tomorrow no steps and then try 1 step again. Small victories at a time!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kristen and Sue,

Thank you. I agree :rolleyes: . Will keep you posted about the progress. I also had one idea about slowing her dow and will show you tomorrow if it works or if it doesn't :D

maja

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The thing about dry training (off stock training of commands) is IMO commands should be learned (felt) in the context of the situation and the stock being worked at that time. Distances and attitudes of both stock and dog are dynamic because it's an interaction between live animals. The effectiveness of a "get back" distance for example is related to the flight zone of the specific stock at that time in a specific situation. What is the flight zone of a ball - a non living object?

 

 

For me, I feel that what you are talking about here is another step in itself, but at the same time a good dog would not have to be "taught" how to respond to a moving Object.. thats where their natural instinct comes in there to want to herd anything..living or non living. Is it not, what these dogs are suppost to do, is herd what the handler wants? I see a working dog as a dog that works with its handler as a team, at lisening to what the handler is saying and obeying those commands and taking the sheep where the handler wants by using these commands. I see each command, come by away to me down on out, as the same as sit, dance pretty, stay, each one is something is something said and the dog does what that word mean. So if the dog knows each command on its own then I see it having a easier time with putting it all together on something live. :D Cause you can work harder and make sure they understand it...with out the "distraction" of moving stock. The dog should be smart enough to put those two things together. Which of course most are...no matter how they are trained :D Then on the other hand, once the dog knows all this, and then I put him/her on stock, then i "help" them understand how to use what he/she already knows on the stock.

 

I deffently understand your point though, which with my dry training is a little different than stated above...with my "training stick" I do make it "come alive" I move the piece of rubber as if it "was alive" which i think makes it a little better than just something standing there like a ball not moving really. Just an example of what ya said..with the on out....you say it depends on the situation on how far they should go out...Well with my commands it is the strenth and stretching of the word that makes them either go out quick and short or far out and slow...I decide right where I want my dog..all by the tone of my vioce....like if i say OOOONNNN OUT!! then they go out fast and far....then if I just say Onn out...then they go out just a ways to let the stock seddle down....which in turn this comes with experience as well....

 

It is really hard to explain in words...which is why I wish I could get my videos to work..but couldnt even get them on photobucket...going to have to just take some more in a different format :rolleyes:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What happens if you take your dog out to a field, but neither you or the dog can see the sheep? When you send your dog out, and your dog still doesn't see them, will the dog continue to look for the sheep, or assume that it's dry training time and look to you for the ball or whatever you're training with?

 

I know that I, personally, am careful not to even use the same commands off stock that I use on stock because if I say, "away to me" ... I want my dog to know there are sheep out there that I want brought back and for the dog to not stop looking until they find it -- whether or not they can see it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...